Daniel Muise

Research

Measuring humans' consumption and provision of information, and simulating it.

2026

White paper, Outset2026

Open-Ended Digital Twins: How We Think About Validation

Daniel Muise, Outset Simulations Lab

White paper

How we validate open-ended twins at Outset: hold-out design, deterministic yardsticks, and measured reference levels.

Abstract

A digital twin is a system that simulates an individual person in their ability to respond to questions and conversations. Nearly all public validation of these systems has happened on closed-ended instruments: surveys, scales, discrete choices. We assert that the more consequential frontier is open-ended responding, and measurement of twins' performance directly in that frame. From the closed-ended and open-ended literatures we derive five commitments for designing and validating our digital twin generation architecture: information-maximizing hold-out processes, determinism underlying validation instruments, thoughtful incorporation of measured reference levels, and grading twins on the distribution of responses their person draws from rather than the string the person happened to say.

Mobile Media & Communication2026

Building Deep Data Through Screens: Princeton-SMART for Mobile Communication Research

Jihye Lee, Kentaro Oriuchi, Daniel Muise, Jacob N Shapiro

Abstract

This article introduces Princeton-SMART, open-source screen-capture software designed to generate deep data on mobile communication behavior. Princeton-SMART unobtrusively collects screenshots and on-screen text from Android devices at short intervals in naturalistic settings. We describe a research pipeline for secure data collection, preprocessing, and analysis, drawing on over 1.5 million screenshots contributed by U.S. job seekers over 6 weeks. We demonstrate how job-search activities can be identified using vision-language AI models and methodological considerations encountered during the process. We conclude by discussing opportunities and practical implications for integrating Princeton-SMART into mobile communication research.

SocArXiv preprint2026

An Open-Source Smartphone Screen-Recording Tool with Application to Political Science Research

Daniel Muise, Justin Cornelius, Jihye Lee, Yingdan Lu, Jacob N Shapiro

Preprint
Abstract

Political scientists seek to understand the political environment and to identify causal relationships within it. This often requires accurate measurement of how individuals consume political information. Many data-collection approaches, particularly those relying on social media content, infer consumption behavior from publicly posted material. Yet public-facing, platform-specific content misrepresents the fragmented, multimedia nature of smartphone use, and thus of political information consumption. Continuous smartphone screen-recording (CSSR) offers a theoretically strong means of capturing individuals' information experience, but has remained largely inaccessible to political scientists due to technical, operational, analytical, and ethical barriers. We introduce an open-source CSSR tool to mitigate these challenges. We motivate its relevance for political science and outline its solutions to practical constraints that have limited CSSR's adoption.

2025

JMIR Formative Research2025

Person-Specific Analyses of Smartphone Use and Mental Health: Intensive Longitudinal Study

Merve Cerit, Angela Y Lee, Jeffrey Hancock, Adam Miner, Mu-Jung Cho, Daniel Muise, Anna-Angelina Garròn Torres, Nick Haber, Nilam Ram, Thomas N Robinson, Byron Reeves

vol. 9, pp. e59875
Abstract

Contrary to popular concerns about the harmful effects of media use on mental health, research on this relationship is ambiguous, stalling advances in theory, interventions, and policy. This exploratory empirical demonstration asks whether mental health effects are associated with media use experiences by redirecting research investments to granular and intensive longitudinal recordings of digital experiences, building models of media use and mental health for single individuals over the course of a year. Smartphone screens were recorded every 5 seconds when devices were in use over 1 year, yielding 6,744,013 screenshots and 123 fortnightly surveys from 5 adult participants. Idiographic filter models revealed substantial person-specific associations between media use and mental health, ranging from r=0.82 to r=0.92, with different combinations of media behaviors and symptoms for each person. Results suggest that the relationships between media use and mental health are highly individualized, with implications for personalized models and precision smartphone-informed interventions.

2024

Journal of Quantitative Description: Digital Media2024

(Mis)measurement of Political Content Exposure within the Smartphone Ecosystem: Investigating Common Assumptions

Daniel Muise, David Markowitz, Byron Reeves, Nilam Ram, Thomas Robinson

APSA 2025 Top Paper, Information Technology and Politics vol. 4
Abstract

The affordances of the smartphone are shifting individuals toward ever smaller and more fragmented units of political experience. We make use of a novel approach to granular assessment of political exposure on smartphones, revealing an incredible level of complexity in modern political content diets, at odds with simplifying assumptions commonly made by political communication research. Based on five million screen-recording frames taken from 119 smartphones over two weeks, we find clear challenges to three common assumptions: (1) that unique encounters with political content can be aggregated by tabulation as though they are equivalent experiences; (2) that durations of exposure can be aggregated at a monthly or daily level without regard for how those time units cluster at smaller timescales; and (3) that singular political formats or sources, particularly news, are sufficient proxies for overall political content exposure. The majority of political content exposure occurs in bursts of only a few potentially forgettable seconds, the remainder follows a power-law curve that reemerges across apps and individuals, and the vast majority of political content is encountered from formats and sources other than news and social media.

2023

arXiv preprint arXiv:2310.001972023

Identification, Impacts, and Opportunities of Three Common Measurement Considerations when using Digital Trace Data

Daniel Muise, Nilam Ram, Thomas Robinson, Byron Reeves

Preprint
Abstract

Cataloguing specific URLs, posts, and applications with digital traces is the new best practice for measuring media use and content consumption. Despite the apparent accuracy that comes with greater granularity, digital traces may introduce additional ambiguity and new errors into the measurement of media use. We identify three new measurement challenges when using digital trace data, uncovered using Screenomics, a framework that records media use at the granularity of individual screenshots every few seconds: (1) entangling, the error introduced by proxying exposure to content by exposure to format; (2) flattening, aggregating unique segments of media interaction without temporal information; and (3) bundling, summing the durations of segments of media interaction indiscriminately across media segments.

2022

Science Advances2022

Quantifying partisan news diets in Web and TV audiences

Daniel Muise, Homa Hosseinmardi, Baird Howland, Markus Mobius, David Rothschild, Duncan J Watts

vol. 8, no. 28, pp. eabn0083

Covered by Ars Technica, Fast Company, Nieman Lab, NBC News, AAAS, and The Daily Show

Abstract

Partisan segregation within the news audience buffers many Americans from countervailing political views, posing a risk to democracy. Empirical studies of the online media ecosystem suggest that only a small minority of Americans are siloed according to their political ideology, but such research omits the comparatively larger television audience and often ignores temporal dynamics. By analyzing billions of browsing and viewing events between 2016 and 2019, with a novel framework for measuring partisan audiences, we estimate that 17% of Americans are partisan-segregated through television versus roughly 4% online. Television news consumers are several times more likely to maintain their partisan news diets month over month, their diets are far more concentrated on preferred sources, and partisan news channels' audiences are growing even as the TV news audience shrinks. Television is the top driver of partisan audience segregation among Americans.

Mobile Media & Communication2022

Selectively localized: Temporal and visual structure of smartphone screen activity across media environments

Daniel Muise, Yingdan Lu, Jennifer Pan, Byron Reeves

Abstract

This study demonstrates how localization and homogenization can co-occur in different aspects of smartphone usage. Smartphones afford individualization of media behavior, shaped by shared environments, yet screen interactions are bounded by nearly identical interfaces. We compare the temporal, visual, and experiential composition of screen activity among individuals in three dissimilar media environments, the United States, China, and Myanmar, using one week of screenshot data captured passively every 5 seconds by the Screenomics framework. Overall usage levels are consistently dissimilar across media environments, while metrics that depend more on moment-level decisions and user-interface design do not vary significantly. Quantitative research on homogenization and localization should analyze behavior driven by user interfaces and by contextually determined parameters, respectively.

Stanford University2022

Temporality of political content exposure via smartphone screens: A computational description of rapidity and idiosyncrasy

Daniel Louis Muise

Dissertation

2021

Human–Computer Interaction2021

Screenomics: A framework to capture and analyze personal life experiences and the ways that technology shapes them

Byron Reeves, Nilam Ram, Thomas N Robinson, James J Cummings, C Lee Giles, Jennifer Pan, Agnese Chiatti, MJ Cho, Katie Roehrick, Xiao Yang, Anupriya Gagneja, Miriam Brinberg, Daniel Muise, Yingdan Lu, Mufan Luo, Andrew Fitzgerald, Leo Yeykelis

vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 150–201
Abstract

Digital experiences capture an increasingly large part of life, making them a preferred, if not required, method to describe and theorize about human behavior. Current methods of recording digital experiences provide only partial reconstructions of digital lives that weave, often within seconds, among multiple applications, locations, functions and media. We describe an end-to-end system for capturing and analyzing the "screenome" of life in media: the record of individual experiences represented as a sequence of screens that people view and interact with over time. The system collects screenshots, extracts text and images, and allows searching of a screenshot database. We discuss how it can elaborate current theories about psychological processing of technology, suggest new questions enabled by multiple time scale analyses, and highlight its capabilities with eight research examples.

2019

Asian Journal of Communication2019

Online field experiments

Daniel Muise, Jennifer Pan

vol. 29, no. 3, pp. 217–234
Abstract

The rapid growth of digitized communications allows new purchase on questions fundamental to communication theories, norms, and practices across Asia. We focus on online field experiments, an approach that can overcome many obstacles to social scientific inquiry but has been used relatively rarely in Asia. We discuss what online field experiments are and how they differ from traditional experiments and from online lab and survey experiments, show how researchers can design and implement them, with attention to legal and ethical considerations, construct validity, randomization and spillover, and statistical analysis, and discuss how they can help researchers make causal inferences on attitudes, behaviors, and interactions that were previously unobservable.

2018

Journal of Experimental Political Science2018

More talk, less need for monitoring: Communication and deterrence in a public good game

David C Kingsley, Daniel Muise

vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 88–106
Abstract

This paper investigates the impact of communication in a public good game with a central authority whose fixed cost increases with the level of monitoring, which in turn determines deterrence. Across three treatments subjects either cannot communicate, communicate only when monitoring is exogenously imposed, or communicate only when monitoring is endogenously selected. Average earnings are significantly higher with the opportunity to communicate. With communication prior to endogenous selection, groups practically eliminate monitoring while maintaining a high level of contributions: communication makes groups less dependent on institutional deterrence and reduces the costs of central authority.

2017

Computation + Journalism Symposium2017

Content over Format: Modern Device Usage and a Realignment of the News Definition

Daniel Muise, Jennifer Pan, Byron Reeves